U.S. import audits are becoming more common than ever, especially for small and mid-sized businesses importing for the first time. With increased restrictions on the $800 De Minimis threshold, increased data analytics, and the formation of new enforcement bodies, even beginners now face stricter scrutiny from U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP).
If you’re an e-commerce seller, a new importer, or a business transitioning from courier shipments to full formal entries, this guide will help you understand exactly how U.S. import audits work and how to prepare so you never get caught off guard.
To understand why enforcement is tightening, read our detailed breakdown of the new DOJ/DHS Trade Fraud Task Force, which has accelerated audit activity across the country:
Why Import Audits Are Rising in 2025
Three major trends are increasing the frequency of audits:
1. The end of the Section 321 / De Minimis “easy mode”
With low-value exemptions significantly restricted, every shipment now requires full documentation, increasing the chances of discrepancies.
Many importers transitioning from courier shipments to full-scale importing face gaps in compliance, explained further here:
2. Data-driven enforcement
CBP uses advanced analytics to scan thousands of entries at once, flagging:
- Inconsistent HS codes
- Suspicious valuation patterns
- Repeated supplier issues
3. DOJ/DHS involvement
The new Trade Fraud Task Force is aggressively targeting misclassification, undervaluation, and improper USMCA claims.
Bottom line:
Being new no longer provides any exemption or leniency. Small importers face the same audit triggers as enterprise-level importers.
What Is a U.S. Import Audit?
A CBP import audit is a formal review to confirm that the information declared at the time of importation was:
- Accurate,
- Complete, and
- Compliant with U.S. customs law.
The audits are conducted by CBP’s Regulatory Audit & Agency Advisory Services (RAAAS), and they may cover:
- Tariff classification
- Valuation
- Country of origin
- Duty calculation
- Admissibility requirements
- Trade program eligibility (USMCA, GSP, etc.)
Audits vs. Exams vs. Notices
It’s important to distinguish these terms:
- Audit: full review of your documentation and import history
- Exam: physical inspection of goods (VACIS, CET, X-ray, tailgate)
- CF-28: Request for Information
- CF-29: Notice of Action (duties owed, penalty risk)
Audits are deeper and more comprehensive than exams, they can span multiple years of data.
What Triggers a U.S. Import Audit?
CBP flags audits based on risk factors. The most common include:
1. Misclassification Patterns
If your HS codes shift between categories or appear inconsistent, CBP will flag your entries for review. This is especially true for high-duty categories like apparel, electronics, and footwear.
2. Undervaluation or Vague Pricing
Valuation issues are the #1 cause of audits. Examples CBP catches:
- Supplier discounts that aren’t reflected
- Inconsistent invoice descriptions
- Missing “assists”
- Bundled product values
If you’re using the First Sale Rule for valuation, documentation must be airtight.
3. Country of Origin Problems
Incorrect origin declarations or improper USMCA claims instantly raise red flags.
Learn how accurate documentation ties to refund opportunities here.
4. Section 321 / De Minimis overuse
Importers moving from courier-based DTC shipping to formal entries often have inaccurate or incomplete documentation.
5. Supplier Quality Issues
If suppliers consistently produce vague or inconsistent invoices, CBP sees the pattern even if you don’t.
6. Random Monitoring
Even fully compliant importers are periodically reviewed.
Types of U.S. Import Audits
Here are the main audit types new importers should know:
1. Quick Query / Focused Assessment (FA)
A limited-scope review focusing on:
- Classification
- Valuation
- Origin
CBP evaluates only the areas that show risk.
2. Comprehensive Audit
A full, deep review covering multiple years of imports.
This can require:
- Financial records
- Supplier agreements
- Transfer pricing documents
- Internal controls
3. Targeted Review & Audit (TRA)
A short, highly focused review usually triggered by:
- Incorrect USMCA claims
- Repeated entry errors
- Origin inconsistencies
Documents You MUST Maintain for an Audit
Importers must keep records for at least 5 years. Required documents include:
- Commercial invoice
- Packing list
- HS code classification notes
- Proof of payment
- Shipping documents (BOL / AWB)
- Country of origin certificates
- USMCA certifications
- PGA documentation (FDA, USDA, CPSC, EPA)
- Purchase orders
- Delivery confirmation
- Internal valuation records
- ISF (for ocean freight)
A standardized documentation system can prevent most audit issues, learn how to set one up.
What Happens During an Audit?
Step 1 — Audit Notice
CBP contacts the importer, specifying scope and timeline.
Step 2 — Initial Data Request
You must submit:
- Entry summaries
- Invoices
- Valuation worksheets
- Classification documents
Step 3 — Risk Assessment Review
CBP evaluates risk indicators like:
- HS code inconsistencies
- Undervaluation patterns
- Missing documents
Step 4 — Documentation Sampling
CBP selects sample entries and examines whether documents support declarations.
Step 5 — Revenue Adjustment
If errors are found, duties and taxes may be owed.
Step 6 — Corrective Action Plan
CBP may require:
- Procedural changes
- Supplier documentation upgrades
- Internal training
Step 7 — Penalties (If Necessary)
More common when importers knowingly ignore errors or fail to respond.
How to Prepare: A Beginner-Friendly Compliance Framework
Here is a simple framework that helps beginners stay audit-proof from day one:
1. Standardize Your Commercial Invoices
Consistency is everything.
- Detailed descriptions
- Quantity + unit price
- Correct HS codes
- Country of origin
- Incoterms
Learn how to build compliant workflows here.
2. Validate HS Codes
Incorrect classification is the #1 cause of duty errors.
- Review codes annually
- Keep a classification database
- Avoid supplier guesswork
3. Strengthen Valuation Controls
Common red flags:
- Vague pricing
- Missing assists
- Inconsistent invoice values
If using First Sale Rule, ensure all documentation is correct.
4. Build Better Supplier Documentation Processes
Suppliers create most documentation errors. Issue clear rules:
- Invoice formatting
- Descriptions
- Country of origin declarations
- Packing list requirements
5. Implement Pre-Clearance with Your Broker
Have a customs broker review documents before goods ship, not after.
6. Maintain Digital Recordkeeping
Centralize your import documents. Digital systems reduce mistakes and speed up responses during an audit.
7. Conduct Mini “Self-Audits”
Basic internal reviews include:
- Comparing tariff codes
- Checking valuations across shipments
- Verifying country-of-origin documentation
These mini-audits also help identify refund opportunities.
Conclusion
U.S. import audits are no longer rare; they’re an expected part of modern importing. But they don’t have to be stressful.
With the right documentation, classification controls, valuation methods, and supplier processes, most issues can be prevented long before CBP becomes involved.
The importers who prepare early are the ones who stay compliant, avoid penalties, and scale with confidence.
For step-by-step guidance on building audit-ready import workflows, start with our beginner-friendly resource.
FAQs
1. How likely is a new importer to be audited?
Higher now than ever due to increased statistical targeting.
2. Do courier shipments get audited?
Yes, CBP can audit any importer’s data, including historical courier entries.
3. How far back can CBP audit?
Up to five years.
4. What happens if I ignore an audit notice?
You may face penalties, duty assessments, or escalated enforcement.
5. Does using First Sale Rule increase audit risk?
Not if implemented correctly with strong documentation.
6. Can my customs broker prevent an audit?
No, but the right broker dramatically reduces audit risk by ensuring accurate filings.
7. Are small importers treated differently?
No. CBP targets patterns, not company size.
8. What’s the difference between an exam and an audit?
An exam inspects goods. An audit inspects your data and documentation.
